KeenVerdict
Home & lifestyle · Verdict

8 Best Pet Insurance of 2026

By the KeenVerdict research desk · Updated November 12, 2026 · Next review December 27, 2026 · 8 products scored

Our pickEmbrace Pet Insuranceowners who want the broadest standard coverage8.9

Our verdict

Embrace includes the most in its standard policy, with dental illness, behavioral therapy and rehab covered and deductibles from $100 to $1,000. Pumpkin is close behind and covers exam fees without an add-on. Spot pays claims in 48 hours or less with no age limit, Lemonade starts at $10 a month and suits app-first owners, and MetLife Pet is the cheapest published accident and illness option at $7 a month for cats. Pets Best sells the cheapest accident-only cover, Figo is the only insurer here with 100% reimbursement, and Trupanion's once-per-condition deductible favors pets with long-term conditions.

The short answer

Embrace is the best pet insurance for most dog and cat owners in 2026 because its standard policy covers dental illness up to $1,000 a year plus behavioral therapy and rehab; Pumpkin suits owners who want vet exam fees covered with no add-on. MetLife Pet has the lowest published accident and illness price, from $7 a month for cats and $16 for dogs as of November 2026, and owners of pets with chronic conditions should look at Trupanion's once-per-condition deductible.

This list is for US dog and cat owners comparing accident and illness insurance. It covers eight insurers that sell policies online today. We compared documented features, policy options and published US prices from each insurer's own website; we did not buy policies or file claims. Premiums depend on your pet's species, breed, age and ZIP code, so the starting prices here are the lowest figures each insurer advertises, often for a young cat or small dog with a high deductible and low annual limit. Healthy Paws, Nationwide, ASPCA Pet Health Insurance and Fetch are not ranked because their websites could not be loaded for checking from our location.

The ranking at a glance

  1. 1Embrace Pet Insuranceowners who want the broadest standard coverage8.9
  2. 2Lemonade Pet Insuranceapp-first owners who bundle insurance8.7
  3. 3Pumpkin Pet Insuranceowners who want exam fees covered by default8.7
  4. 4Spot Pet Insuranceowners who want fast claims and no age limit8.7
  5. 5MetLife Pet Insurancemulti-pet households and employer plans8.6
  6. 6Pets Bestowners who want a cheap accident-only plan8.6
  7. 7Figo Pet Insuranceowners who want 100% reimbursement8.5
  8. 8Trupanionowners of breeds prone to chronic conditions8.4

How we scored

Every product gets the same three scores out of 10. We compared documented features and published prices; we did not run hands-on tests.

  • 40%Features
  • 30%Ease of use
  • 30%Value

Full scoring method

  1. No. 1, our pick

    Embrace Pet Insurance

    Accident and illness insurance for dogs and cats that includes dental illness, behavioral therapy and rehab in the standard policy.

    8.9of 10

    Best for owners who want the broadest standard coverage

    Features
    9.4
    Ease of use
    8.6
    Value
    8.4

    Price

    Quote-based; Embrace says most dog owners pay $20 to $70 a month

    Quoted from the Embrace Pet Insurance pricing page on November 12, 2026: most Embrace dog parents pay between $20–$70/month

    Embrace takes the top spot because its standard policy covers more than most rivals before you add anything. Dental illness such as periodontal disease, extractions and tooth resorption is covered up to $1,000 per policy year, and vet-supervised behavioral therapy plus rehab treatments like acupuncture, hydrotherapy and physical rehab are included. You set an annual deductible between $100 and $1,000, a 70%, 80% or 90% reimbursement rate, and an annual limit from $2K up to unlimited. Accidents are covered from the moment the policy takes effect, and the illness waiting period is two weeks. Embrace may also cover curable pre-existing conditions once a pet has gone 12 months without symptoms or treatment, which helps owners of pets with a past ear infection or UTI. The trade-offs are add-ons: exam fee coverage and prescription drug coverage cost extra, so the advertised premium does not include everything a typical vet visit bills.

    What works

    • +Curable pre-existing conditions may be covered after 12 months free of symptoms and treatment
    • +Behavioral therapy for anxiety, aggression and litter box issues is included
    • +Embrace says more than 90% of claims are paid in under 10 days

    What does not

    • −Vet exam fees need a paid add-on
    • −Prescription drug coverage is an extra add-on
    • −Wellness Rewards is a separate membership, not insurance, and is not sold in Rhode Island
    Reimbursement
    70%, 80% or 90%
    Deductible
    $100 to $1,000 per year
    Annual limit
    $2K to unlimited
    Illness waiting period
    Two weeks

    Visit embracepetinsurance.com|Read the full Embrace Pet Insurance review

  2. No. 2

    Lemonade Pet Insurance

    App-based pet insurance from $10 a month with 70% to 90% co-insurance and preventative care packages.

    8.7of 10

    Best for app-first owners who bundle insurance

    Features
    8.0
    Ease of use
    9.3
    Value
    9.0

    Price

    From $10 a month for a dog or cat

    Quoted from the Lemonade Pet Insurance pricing page on November 12, 2026: At Lemonade, a policy for a dog or a cat starts at $10/month.

    Lemonade suits owners who want to handle everything in an app and pay as little as possible. A dog or cat policy starts at $10 a month, and Lemonade adds a 10% discount for bundling with its renters, home or car insurance, 5% for insuring several pets and 5% for paying annually. You choose 70%, 80% or 90% co-insurance and an annual limit between $5,000 and $100,000. Claims are filed in the app, and Lemonade says it pays 50% of eligible claims instantly. Preventative packages cover a wellness exam, up to 3 vaccines and, on higher tiers, a routine dental cleaning, with no deductible or waiting period. The base policy is narrower than Embrace or Pumpkin: vet visit fees and physical therapy are add-ons, pre-existing conditions are not covered, and orthopedic conditions such as cruciate ligament problems carry a 30-day waiting period. Claims must be filed within 180 days, or 90 days in Texas.

    What works

    • +Starting price of $10 a month is among the lowest published
    • +Quote, coverage changes and claims run in the Lemonade app
    • +Flea, tick and heartworm medicine bought at Chewy or Costco can be reimbursed on some preventative packages

    What does not

    • −Pre-existing conditions are not covered
    • −Vet visit fees and physical therapy are paid add-ons
    • −30-day waiting period for orthopedic conditions, longer than the 14-day illness wait
    Starting price
    $10 a month
    Co-insurance
    70%, 80% or 90%
    Annual limit
    $5,000 to $100,000
    Waiting periods
    14 days illness, 30 days orthopedic

    Visit lemonade.com|Read the full Lemonade Pet Insurance review

  3. No. 3

    Pumpkin Pet Insurance

    Dog and cat insurance with 80% or 90% reimbursement that covers exam fees, dental illness and behavioral issues without add-ons.

    8.7of 10

    Best for owners who want exam fees covered by default

    Features
    9.1
    Ease of use
    8.8
    Value
    8.1

    Price

    See vendor pricing (USD check pending)

    US price check pending. See the Pumpkin Pet Insurance pricing page.

    Pumpkin is the runner-up because it removes many of the add-ons other insurers charge for. In-office and virtual vet exam fees for accident and illness visits are covered, as are dental illness, behavioral issues and alternative therapies, with no extra monthly fee. Every pet from 8 weeks old, seniors included, can choose an 80% or 90% reimbursement rate and an annual limit from $5k to unlimited, and Pumpkin says it has no upper age limits or breed restrictions. Its single waiting period of 14 days or less applies to all conditions, including knee injuries and hip dysplasia, where several rivals impose longer orthopedic waits. For expensive emergencies, PumpkinNow can fast-track eligible claims over $500 and pay up to 90% in minutes. The drawbacks: Pumpkin does not offer a 70% rate for owners who want a cheaper premium, and its former Preventive Essentials add-on stopped selling on August 18, 2026, replaced by a separate Wellness Club membership.

    What works

    • +No upper age limits or breed restrictions
    • +No extra fees for dental illness, behavioral or exam fee coverage
    • +Curable pre-existing conditions such as a UTI may be covered once cured

    What does not

    • −No 70% reimbursement option to lower the premium
    • −Preventive Essentials was withdrawn on August 18, 2026; routine care moved to the Pumpkin Wellness Club
    • −Prices are only shown after a quote
    Reimbursement
    80% or 90%
    Annual limit
    $5k to unlimited
    Waiting period
    14 days or less for all conditions
    Minimum age
    8 weeks

    Visit pumpkin.care|Read the full Pumpkin Pet Insurance review

  4. No. 4

    Spot Pet Insurance

    Accident-only and accident and illness plans for dogs and cats, with up to 90% reimbursement and an optional wellness add-on.

    8.7of 10

    Best for owners who want fast claims and no age limit

    Features
    8.7
    Ease of use
    8.7
    Value
    8.7

    Price

    From $9 a month for cats and $15 a month for dogs

    Quoted from the Spot Pet Insurance pricing page on November 12, 2026: Cat Insurance Starting from $9/mo

    Spot balances price and coverage better than most insurers on this list. Cat plans start at $9 a month and dog plans at $15 a month, though Spot notes the dog figure is based on an 80% reimbursement rate, a $500 deductible and a $2,500 annual limit for a 2-year-old small mixed breed. You can choose an accident-only plan or an accident and illness plan, then set the annual limit, deductible and a reimbursement rate of up to 90%. Hereditary, congenital and breed-specific conditions are covered with no breed exclusions, and behavioral modification is included. Spot says claims are reimbursed in 48 hours or less and take about 30 seconds to submit online. There is no upper age limit, no lifetime cap and a 30-day money back guarantee, and you can use any licensed vet in the US or Canada. Wellness exams, vaccines and dental cleanings need the paid wellness add-on.

    What works

    • +No upper age limit and no lifetime caps
    • +30-day money back guarantee
    • +Visit any licensed vet in the US or Canada

    What does not

    • −The advertised $15 dog premium assumes a $2,500 annual limit and a $500 deductible
    • −Wellness coverage costs extra
    • −Premiums can rise with your pet's age at renewal
    Starting price
    $9/mo cats, $15/mo dogs
    Reimbursement
    Up to 90%
    Claim payout
    48 hours or less
    Age limit
    None

    Visit spotpet.com|Read the full Spot Pet Insurance review

  5. No. 5

    MetLife Pet Insurance

    One customizable accident and illness plan for dogs and cats, with a family plan for several pets and deductibles from $0.

    8.6of 10

    Best for multi-pet households and employer plans

    Features
    8.6
    Ease of use
    8.4
    Value
    8.9

    Price

    From $7 a month for cats and $16 a month for dogs

    Quoted from the MetLife Pet Insurance pricing page on November 12, 2026: MetLife Pet plans start at $7 per month for cats and $16 per month for dogs.

    MetLife Pet is the strongest pick for households with several animals and for people who can enroll through work. It sells one accident and illness plan and lets you tune it with a reimbursement rate of 50%, 70%, 80% or 90%, an annual benefit limit and a deductible anywhere from $0 to $750 in $50 steps, or $1,000 to $2,500 for a lower premium. If you do not receive a claim reimbursement in a policy year, the deductible drops by $50. Plans start at $7 a month for cats and $16 for dogs, and the example plans on its site run from $12 to $52 a month depending on limit and deductible. The Family Plan puts several pets on one policy, and employer enrollment can bring discounts. Exam fees for accidents and illnesses are covered, and MetLife says claims are typically processed within 5 days. Routine wellness needs the Preventive Care add-on.

    What works

    • +Cheapest published accident and illness price on this list at $7 a month for cats
    • +Widest deductible range we found, starting at $0
    • +Pets cannot age out of accident and illness coverage

    What does not

    • −The cheapest example plans carry a $2,000 annual benefit
    • −Preventive Care is a paid add-on
    • −Diminishing deductible is not offered everywhere and restrictions apply
    Starting price
    $7/mo cats, $16/mo dogs
    Reimbursement
    50%, 70%, 80% or 90%
    Deductible
    $0 to $2,500
    Claims
    Typically processed within 5 days

    Visit metlifepetinsurance.com|Read the full MetLife Pet Insurance review

  6. No. 6

    Pets Best

    Accident and illness and accident-only plans for dogs and cats with direct vet pay and no upper age limit.

    8.6of 10

    Best for owners who want a cheap accident-only plan

    Features
    8.5
    Ease of use
    8.4
    Value
    8.9

    Price

    Accident-only plans from $9 a month for dogs and $6 for cats

    Quoted from the Pets Best pricing page on November 12, 2026: Fixed rate Accident Only plans are available for $9/month

    Pets Best is the pick for owners who mainly want protection against accidents at the lowest fixed price. Its accident-only plans cost $9 a month for dogs and $6 a month for cats, or $10 and $7 in Washington, and cover injuries such as broken bones, swallowed objects, bite wounds and poisoning. Owners who want fuller cover can buy an accident and illness plan and choose the deductible, reimbursement rate and annual limit; Pets Best's own sales data put typical dog premiums at $36 to $58 a month and cats at $22 to $34. All plans include Direct Vet Pay, which lets Pets Best pay a participating vet directly, and a 24/7 pet helpline at no extra cost. There are no upper age limits, and you can visit any licensed vet in the US or Canada. Wellness add-ons cover routine exams, vaccines and dental cleanings. The cost averages are dated, so get a quote for current rates.

    What works

    • +No upper age limits for coverage
    • +Use any licensed vet in the US or Canada
    • +Pets Best reports more than 1 million pets enrolled and $1.3 billion in covered claims

    What does not

    • −Accident-only plans do not cover illnesses
    • −Published accident and illness averages of $36 to $58 a month for dogs come from 2022 to 2023 sales data
    • −Accident-only plans cost more in Washington state
    Starting price
    $9/mo dogs, $6/mo cats (accident-only)
    Age limit
    None
    Direct vet pay
    Yes, all plans
    Helpline
    24/7, included

    Visit petsbest.com|Read the full Pets Best review

  7. No. 7

    Figo Pet Insurance

    Three accident and illness plans with up to 100% reimbursement, the Pet Cloud app and optional Powerups.

    8.5of 10

    Best for owners who want 100% reimbursement

    Features
    8.8
    Ease of use
    8.6
    Value
    7.9

    Price

    See vendor pricing (USD check pending)

    US price check pending. See the Figo Pet Insurance pricing page.

    Figo stands out for owners who would rather pay a higher premium than share the bill. It is the only insurer we compared that lets you pick up to 100% reimbursement, and it does not cap payments per incident or condition. You choose one of three plans by annual limit: Essential at $5,000, Preferred at $10,000 or Ultimate with no annual limit, then set the deductible and reimbursement rate. Claims are filed in the Pet Cloud app, and Figo says most close in 3 working days on average, based on its 2025 claims data. Policyholders get free 24/7 Live Vet access, and curable pre-existing conditions may be covered after 12 months without signs or symptoms. Coverage applies at a licensed vet of your choice, worldwide. Exam fees and wellness care are sold as paid Powerups, and Figo does not publish a starting price, so you need a quote to compare it.

    What works

    • +Only insurer we compared that publishes a 100% reimbursement option
    • +Curable pre-existing conditions may be covered after 12 months without signs or symptoms
    • +Visit a licensed vet of your choice, worldwide

    What does not

    • −Vet exam fees for accidents and illnesses are a paid Powerup
    • −Wellness coverage is also a paid Powerup
    • −Prices are only shown after you enter your pet's details
    Reimbursement
    Up to 100%
    Annual limit
    $5,000, $10,000 or unlimited
    Average claim time
    3 working days
    Underwriter
    Independence American Insurance Company

    Visit figopetinsurance.com|Read the full Figo Pet Insurance review

  8. No. 8

    Trupanion

    Lifetime-deductible pet insurance that pays 90% and settles bills directly with 11,000+ partner vets.

    8.4of 10

    Best for owners of breeds prone to chronic conditions

    Features
    9.0
    Ease of use
    8.9
    Value
    7.0

    Price

    See vendor pricing (USD check pending)

    US price check pending. See the Trupanion pricing page.

    Trupanion works differently from every other insurer on this list. Instead of an annual deductible, you pay a deductible of $0 to $1,000 once per condition, and that condition stays covered for as long as you are a member, so a dog with diabetes or allergies does not restart the deductible every year. Trupanion pays 90% of covered costs with no payout limits, and it says it will not raise your rate just because your pet gets older. Its VetDirect Pay system lets more than 11,000 partner clinics in the US and Canada send claims and get paid at checkout, in about 5 minutes on average, so you only pay your 10% share. Hereditary and breed-specific conditions such as hip dysplasia and IVDD are covered. The trade-offs are cost and scope: Trupanion does not publish a starting price, there is only one 90% rate, and vet exam fees, taxes and wellness care are excluded.

    What works

    • +Per-condition deductible means chronic conditions do not reset each year
    • +No price increases just because a pet has a birthday, per Trupanion
    • +Trupanion reports $4B+ paid in vet claims and over 98% of members renewing

    What does not

    • −Vet exam fees and taxes are not covered
    • −Wellness care is not included
    • −Only one reimbursement rate, 90%, so you cannot lower it to cut the premium
    Reimbursement
    90%
    Deductible
    $0 to $1,000 per condition, once
    Payout limits
    None
    Direct vet pay
    11,000+ partner clinics

    Visit trupanion.com|Read the full Trupanion review

Before you choose

Compare the deductible type, not just the amount

Most insurers use an annual deductible that resets each policy year: Embrace offers $100 to $1,000 and MetLife Pet $0 to $2,500. Trupanion instead charges $0 to $1,000 once per condition, which costs less over time for a pet with a chronic illness but more for a pet with many small one-off problems.

Pick a reimbursement rate you can live with

A higher rate raises the premium. MetLife Pet offers 50% to 90%, Embrace and Lemonade 70% to 90%, Pumpkin 80% or 90%, Trupanion only 90%, and Figo goes up to 100%. On a $5,000 surgery after the deductible, the gap between 70% and 90% is $1,000 out of your pocket.

Check what the base policy leaves out

Exam fees are the most common gap. Pumpkin and MetLife Pet cover exam fees for accidents and illnesses, while Embrace, Figo and Lemonade sell them as add-ons and Trupanion excludes them. Every insurer here excludes pre-existing conditions, though Embrace, Figo and Pumpkin may cover curable ones after a symptom-free period.

Read the waiting periods

Lemonade has a 14-day illness wait and a 30-day wait for orthopedic conditions such as cruciate ligament tears. Pumpkin applies 14 days or less to all conditions, including hip dysplasia. Enroll while your pet is young and healthy so fewer issues count as pre-existing.

Treat advertised prices as a floor

Spot's $15 dog premium assumes an 80% rate, a $500 deductible and a $2,500 annual limit for a 2-year-old small mixed breed. MetLife Pet's own examples for dogs run from $24 to $52 a month. Get quotes with the same deductible, rate and limit at two or three insurers before you decide.

Questions readers ask

What is the best pet insurance in 2026?
Embrace is our top pick for most dog and cat owners. Its standard policy covers dental illness up to $1,000 a year, behavioral therapy and rehab, with deductibles from $100 to $1,000 and 70% to 90% reimbursement. Pumpkin is the runner-up for owners who want exam fees included.
What is the cheapest pet insurance?
MetLife Pet has the lowest published accident and illness price, from $7 a month for cats and $16 for dogs. For accident-only cover, Pets Best charges $6 a month for cats and $9 for dogs. Your quote will depend on breed, age and ZIP code.
How much does pet insurance cost per month?
Most owners pay roughly $20 to $70 a month for a dog. Embrace says most of its dog owners pay $20 to $70 and Spot says its dog owners pay an average of $40 a month, with cats costing less at an average of $22.
Does pet insurance cover pre-existing conditions?
No, none of the insurers on this list cover pre-existing conditions. Embrace, Figo and Pumpkin may cover a curable condition, such as a urinary tract infection, if it has been cured and symptom-free for a set period, typically 12 months at Embrace and Figo.
Which pet insurance pays the vet directly?
Trupanion pays vets directly through VetDirect Pay at more than 11,000 partner clinics in the US and Canada. Pets Best also offers Direct Vet Pay on all plans, and Pumpkin's PumpkinNow can pay up to 90% of eligible claims over $500 before you pay the vet.
Is there pet insurance with no age limit?
Yes. Pumpkin, Spot and Pets Best publish no upper age limit for enrollment, and MetLife Pet says pets will not age out of accident and illness coverage. Premiums usually rise as pets get older.
Does pet insurance cover vet exam fees?
It depends on the insurer. Pumpkin and MetLife Pet cover exam fees for accident and illness visits, Embrace and Figo sell exam fee coverage as an add-on, Lemonade sells a vet visit fee add-on, and Trupanion excludes exam fees.

Questions or corrections: editorial@keenverdict.com

Read our disclosure and editorial policy. Prices change often; check the vendor page before you buy.

More verdicts